Why Off-the-Shelf Shopify Themes Hold Stores Back in 2025

Off-the-shelf themes are designed to work for as many industries as possible. Skincare, clothing, gadgets, furniture. All from one codebase and the same set of Shopify 2.0sections.

That means bloated feature sets, overly complex settings, and sections that aren’t truly relevant to your unique customer journey.

So instead of having a site designed around your products and customers needs, you’re cramming your business into a framework built for someone else.

For example a store selling fashion would require drop notices, countdowns and shop the look sections. Whereas a store selling food items wouldn’t need any of these and instead would prioritise different functionality around the shopping journey on the collection page.

“You didn’t build a cookie-cutter business — so why use a cookie-cutter website?”

Many themes are built to look good out of the box — but under the hood, they can be slow and clunky.

They often:

• Load lots of unused scripts and animations.
• Include integrations you don’t use.
• Aren’t optimised for your real-world image or content needs.
• Have lots of features and settings you would never use

That’s a big issue when it comes to mobile shoppers and SEO.

Stat: A 1-second delay in page load time can reduce conversions by up to 20% (source: Portent).

If you want to learn more about how site speed affects SEO and sales, Google’s Page Experience Guide is a great place to start.

Most pre-made themes let you “drag and drop” sections around, but only within certain boundaries. Try to do something slightly different — and suddenly you’re in the code editor, fiddling with Liquid or CSS.

This often leads to:

• Frankensteined layouts and clashing styles.
• Rigid templates that don’t fit the product.
• A design you’re always “working around.”

By contrast, custom design starts with the customer experience — not a predetermined template.

If you want to explore Shopify theme development, Shopify’s official Liquid documentation is an excellent resource.

There are hundreds of thousands of stores using the same themes — many even leave the demo text and colour palette untouched.

That doesn’t exactly inspire trust. And in competitive markets, that lack of uniqueness is a conversion killer.

“Your brand is more than your logo — it’s how your entire online experience feels.”

 Remember: Customers make snap judgments. If your store looks just like a dozen others, why should they believe your product is better?

Trust is one of the biggest drivers when it comes to sales, and if someone notices the same theme being used from a previous shopping experience, this will increase the abandonment rate.

Themes can’t anticipate how your buyers behave.

• Do they compare lots of similar products before deciding?
• Do they need education or reassurance?
• Do they buy quickly on mobile while commuting?

These details matter — and most themes aren’t built with those in mind.

A good Shopify designer studies your business, market and analytics to map out a user journey that fits your funnel, not someone else’s.

This is tackled with the UX review I undertake before every project

Let’s be clear — themes can be a good starting point, especially if:

• You’re launching a side project.
• You have a tiny product range.
• You’re testing a new concept with minimal budget.